Monetisation

2024

Why customers didn't purchase the Suite, and what we shipped instead

Sage wanted to sell a new small business proposition with Accounting, Payroll and HR as one Suite while keeping the pricing structure same. I led the e-commerce flow and a 3-round research and A/B testing programme that put the proposition in front of live traffic.

Role

Experience Designer

Team

Research

PMM

Web Delivery and Optimisation

Impact

-32% net conversion

Prevented a costly company-wide rollout

+41% bundle conversion with multi-product intent

Shipped fix: +15% payroll attach rate

Role

Experience Designer

Team

Research

PMM

Web Delivery and Optimisation

Impact

-32% net conversion

Prevented a costly company-wide rollout

+41% bundle conversion with multi-product intent

Shipped fix: +15% payroll attach rate

Problem area

A commercial test with no pricing change

Sage sell Accounting, Payroll and HR software to UK and Ireland small businesses. Each product had its own buying journey, its own page, its own plans. The business decided to move to a single promise,โ€œOne solution for all your business needsโ€.

The commercial architecture underneath was not up for discussion. Same tiers, same prices, same plan structure continued as they were. So the entire proposition was relying on if the design alone could change what people bought.

Ambition

Higher order value, acquisition revenue, attach rate and retention, plus more efficient marketing spend.

Ambition

Higher order value, acquisition revenue, attach rate and retention, plus more efficient marketing spend.

Constraints

No change in commercial architecture.

Constraints

No change in commercial architecture.

Constraints

No change in commercial architecture.

Design goals

Suite to run a business rather than a stack of products

We created a hypothesis to test:

Small businesses are looking for a solution to run their businesses, not just a software. If the journey leads with the solution and lets people configure what they need, they'll see the value and buy with confidence.

Lead with the jobs-to-do

Show what the business needs to be done.

Lead with the jobs-to-do

Show what the business needs to be done.

A personalised solution

Make it feel like configuring depending on needs instead of adding on extras.

Confidence in the choice

Remove friction in plan selection

Confidence in the choice

Remove friction in plan selection

How we tested

Three rounds of experimentation to understand comprehension using moderated research and live A/B test to see impact on metrics.

Design decision 01

Reframe a product page as a business plan

The default page sold Accounting plans and showed Payroll as an add-on. I reframed it as one Small Business plan and added a step-flow, so choosing Accounting reads as step 1 of a configuration, not the whole purchase.

1

Suite: one plan for the business

2

Step flow to show configuration

3

CTA label: choose and "add"

What we learned

Research proved the suites proposition landed well

People read the page as one solution

Behaviour said otherwise

Single-product buyers wanted a clear path out. More on this in Decision 03.

Design decision 02

Move the second product to step two

In the old journey, Payroll arrived as an add-on modal just before checkout. I moved it into the flow as step 2, carrying the Accounting choice forward, and made skipping it as visible as choosing it.

1

Step flow and summary: Accounting tier is selected and editable.

2

Opting out of Payroll is visible next to the prompt

2

Opting out of Payroll is visible next to the prompt

3

Combined price with no bundle advantage

3

Combined price with no bundle advantage

What we learned

Opting out was easier

Users saw and skipped the step when needed

Step flow wasn't seen

Only 20% noticed it, so it was removed in the next round

Design decision 03

Show the whole plan on one page

Previous round showed users treated Accounting as the whole product. Once they'd chosen a plan, they felt flow was done, and Payroll in step 2 came as a surprise. So I put all choices including the standalone product cards in a section before configuration.

1

Suite-first with standalone products

Suite is recommended, but Accounting and Payroll only are also available for users who came for one product.

2

Clear pricing expectations

"From" pricing prepares the user for the cost before starting configuration.

2

Clear pricing expectations

"From" pricing prepares the user for the cost before starting configuration.

3

All plans on one page

Accounting and Payroll sit together, and checkboxes make adding or skipping a product visually easy.

4

Plan total

Pricing and savings update with every choice, so the cost is visible before checkout.

What we learned

What it fixed

Skipping a product became as easy as adding one.

What it fixed

Skipping a product became as easy as adding one.

What it couldn't fix

Suite pricing is exactly the sum of its plans. Making the total visible made the missing value visible too.

What it couldn't fix

Suite pricing is exactly the sum of its plans. Making the total visible made the missing value visible too.

What it showed

Giving users the choice wasn't enough. Even with a single-product path on the first screen, single-product sales still dropped.

Retrospective

What we learned after losing the bet

What I was handed

A business ambition to sell multiple products as one, with same pricing and plans. Payroll was sold through a modal just before checkout.

What I was handed

A business ambition to sell multiple products as one, with same pricing and plans. Payroll was sold through a modal just before checkout.

What exists now

A company-wide rollout stopped before it shipped on a wrong assumption. Proof that the suite works for people who want more than one product. A rebuilt add-on modal, live.

What exists now

A company-wide rollout stopped before it shipped on a wrong assumption. Proof that the suite works for people who want more than one product. A rebuilt add-on modal, live.

What exists now

A company-wide rollout stopped before it shipped on a wrong assumption. Proof that the suite works for people who want more than one product. A rebuilt add-on modal, live.

Before

No hierarchy: features and price compete Opting out was hard to find Complex plan definitions and interface

After

Value-first simplified content Radio buttons to choose Pricing visible at a glance

Impact

Stopped a costly rollout

During 3 rounds: -32% total conversion +41% multi-product purchases

Stopped a costly rollout

During 3 rounds: -32% total conversion +41% multi-product purchases

Found who the Suite is for

Users buying more than one product converted +41% better. The suite has an audience, just not everyone.

Found who the Suite is for

Users buying more than one product converted +41% better. The suite has an audience, just not everyone.

Research โ‰  behaviour

Users understood the Suite in research but didn't buy it in the live test. Comprehension wasn't enough for conversion.

Research โ‰  behaviour

Users understood the Suite in research but didn't buy it in the live test. Comprehension wasn't enough for conversion.

Showing options isn't routing

A single-product path on the first screen didn't protect single-product sales.

Showing options isn't routing

A single-product path on the first screen didn't protect single-product sales.

What I'd do differently

Change one thing at a time. Decision 3 changed many things at once, so when conversion dropped, telling the main reason was difficult. And I'd test the Suite with existing customers first, where the users most likely to want a second product.

Change one thing at a time. Decision 3 changed many things at once, so when conversion dropped, telling the main reason was difficult. And I'd test the Suite with existing customers first, where the users most likely to want a second product.

Designed by Fulya, last updated: November 2026

fulyatras@proton.me

fulyatras@proton.me

Designed by Fulya, last updated: November 2026

fulyatras@proton.me

fulyatras@proton.me

Designed by Fulya, last updated: November 2026

fulyatras@proton.me

fulyatras@proton.me

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.